Torture free essays, term papers and book reports

Does torture necessarily involve coercion? No doubt the threat oftorture, and torture in its preliminary stages, simply functions as aform of coercion in this sense. However, torture proper has as itsstarting point the failure of coercion, or that coercion is not evengoing to be attempted. As we have seen, torture proper targets autonomyitself, and seeks to overwhelm the capacity of the victims to exerciserational control over their decisions—at least in relation tocertain matters for a limited period of time—by literallyterrorising them into submission. Hence there is a close affinitybetween terrorism and torture. Indeed, arguably torture is a terroristtactic. However, it is one that can be used by groups other thanterrorists, e.g. it can be used against enemy combatants by armiesfighting conventional wars and deploying conventional militarystrategies. In relation to the claim that torture is not coercion, itmight be responded that at least some forms or instances of tortureinvolve coercion, namely those in which the torturer is seekingsomething from the victim, e.g. information, and in which some degreeof rational control to comply or not with the torturer's wishes isretained by the victim. This response is plausible. However, even ifthe response is accepted, there will remain instances of torture inwhich these above-mentioned conditions do not obtain; presumably, thesewill not be instances of coercion.

torture Free Essays, Term Papers and book reports. Thousands of papers to select from all free.

The person being tortured is for the duration of the torturingprocess physically powerless in relation to the torturer. By“physically powerless” two things are meant: the victim isdefenceless, i.e., the victim cannot prevent the torturer fromtorturing the victim, and the victim is unable to attack, and thereforephysically harm, the torturer. Nevertheless, it does not follow fromthis that the victim is entirely powerless vis-à-vis thetorturer. For the victim might be able to strongly influence thetorturer's actions, either by virtue of having at this time the powerto harm people other than the torturer, or by virtue of having at somefuture time the power to defend him/herself against the torturer,and/or attack the torturer. Consider the clichéd example of theterrorist who is refusing to disclose to the torturer the whereaboutsof a bomb with a timing device which is about to explode in a crowdedmarket-place. Perhaps the terrorist could negotiate the cessation oftorture and immunity for himself, if he talks. Consider also asituation in which both a hostage and his torturer know that it is onlya matter of an hour before the police arrive, free the hostage andarrest the torturer; perhaps the hostage is a defence official who isrefusing to disclose the whereabouts of important military documentsand who is strengthened in his resolve by this knowledge of the limitedduration of the pain being inflicted upon him.

Custom Waterboarding as a Method of Torture essay writing

Torture essays,a personal narrative essay - Hanson & Fitch The majority of people find torture unnecessary and claim that it is not effective any more. There are many other ways to prove whether the person it telling the truth and to get information from him, as the technologies nowadays are advanced and other techniques can be also used. According to Most Americans Oppose Torture Techniques (2004), “Given pro and con arguments, 63 percent in an ABC News/Washington Post poll say torture is never acceptable, even when other methods fail and authorities believe the suspect has information that could prevent terrorist attacks. Thirty-five percent say torture is acceptable in some such cases.”

Final Exam: Torture Report Essay Questions – Latest

Thesis: Torture is unacceptable, as all human beings have their rights, and there are other modern ways of punishment and ways to get information from people. Many experts find torture unnecessary and claim that it is not effective any more.

[tags: Human Torture Essays] :: 4 Works Cited, 1140 words